February 9, 2008
In the Good Old Summertime (1949) ***1/2
Directed by Robert Z. Leonard
I must first emphasize two unfortunate realities surrounding Leonard's squeaky clean musical. First of all, one of the great cinematic geniuses of all time, Buster Keaton, is absolutely wasted! Second, Judy Garland comes off like a drag queen whenever she sings up tempo. I'm not sure I've witnessed a worse musical number (with the exception of everything Pierce Brosnon sings in Mamma Mia!) than Garland singing "I Don't Care." That being said, there would be no Shop Around the Corner or You've Got Mail without their predecessor. This is one you can watch with your grandmother, your five year old and your dog and not worry about any objectionable content. Despite its flaws, this is a good old film!
Labels: 1940s, Musical, Van Johnson, Three and a Half Stars
The Wrestler (2008) *****Directed by Darren Aronofsky
Glorious, brutal and heartbreaking are the first words that come to mind when I think about the grand experience I had watching The Wrestler. Everyone's talking about Mickey Rourke's performance, and in my opinion, the hype is an undersell. Rourke's performance is possibly the best of the modern film era. The story of a wrestler twenty years past his prime mirrors many of the struggles of Rourke's life, and yet, there's not an ounce of unwarranted self-pity or sentimentality
on screen. Marissa Tomei gives the supporting female performance of the year, and hats off to her for the courage she displays on screen. The Wrestler is a tragedy at its core, and yet, I can't imagine anyone leaving this film without an overwhelming sense of appreciation for the magic just witnessed on screen.
Labels: 2008, Drama, Five Stars
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2008) **1/2
Directed by David Fincher
"If there's only one version of Forrest Gump you're going to see this year, make it The Curious Case of Benjamin Button!" So says an internet video that lays out all of the ways Gump screenwriter Eric Roth recycles his own material into this bloated, self-important, gimmicky morality tale. Hurricane Katrina inexplicably serves as a backdrop as the life story is told about a man who ages backwards. Brad Pitt is just awful as Benjamin Button, relying on that silly "sexy gaze" of his to try and twitter the hearts of women everywhere. (Isn't it nice to see twitter used in its original context?) Yes, the film is gorgeous, the effects are innovative and impressive and the supporting performances, especially from Tilda Swinton, aren't bad. Still, when Benjamin's age regression reaches its logical conclusion, I was laughing out loud while others in the theater were sniffling. Suckers!
Labels: 2008, Drama, Best Picture Oscar Nominees, Two and a Half Stars
A Christmas Tale (2008) ****1/2
Directed by Arnaud Desplechin
You might think that a film with such a generic title might be a heartwarming holiday tale much like the corny Christmas movies my parents watch on the Hallmark Channel. On the contrary, the French film A Christmas Tale takes us on an unflinching journey into one of the most dysfunctional families ever on screen. Still lovely Catherine Deneuve stars as the matriarch of the family who needs a bone marrow transplant. The only possible donor is her grandson, a troubled, suicidal fifteen year old boy who is the bane of his family's existence. Just as everyone agrees to allow the boy to go through this painful, somewhat dangerous procedure, her middle son shows up for Christmas with the results of his test which say that he too is a donor. Everyone deals with the problems that ensue in their own unique ways, allowing for a glorious meditation on the unconditional love of family.
Labels: 2008, Drama, Foreign Film, French, Four and a Half Stars
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008) *1/2
Directed by Steven Spielberg
I could take or leave the Indiana Jones series, and after this fourth installment, I'm leaning heavily towards leaving it in the hole that Spielberg and Lucas dug for it. This CGI-laced adventure is so artificial, so soulless that I couldn't believe it made that much money. I'm surprised people didn't throw stink bombs in the theater in protest of the fact that a more disappointing Indiana Jones couldn't be made. Shia LeBeouf overacts, which is good for Harrison Ford since he looks better in comparison. There are clunky attempts to add nostalgia with details from the previous films peppered throughout. There's a twist ending which could only come from the minds of Lucas and Spielberg (at their most egotistical) which had me rolling my eyes in disgust
. Maybe copies of the DVD could be used as target practice for those looking to master their whip-cracking skills!
Labels: 2008, Action, One and a Half Stars